TIGRAN SAHAKYAN
Turkey’s Continuing Genocide Against the Armenians
ТИГРАН СААКЯН
Продолжаемый Турцией геноцид армян
ՏԻԳՐԱՆ ՍԱՀԱԿՅԱՆ
Թուրքիայի կողմից շարունակվող Հայոց ցեղասպանությունը
Yerevan-Lusakn-2026
Preface
This work addresses Turkey’s international responsibility for the ongoing Armenian Genocide. It proceeds from the premise that halting this international crime and remedying its consequences is a task that concerns not just the entire Armenian nation but humanity as a whole. Effectively ending and redressing this ongoing genocide requires the political will of all states across the world—and, first and foremost, that of the great powers. Only Turkey’s official recognition of the Armenian Genocide and its clear and unequivocal acceptance of responsibility for this crime can provide a tangible guarantee that genocide will never happen again. Until the victims of the Armenian Genocide have been made whole—with their most fundamental rights to their homeland, property, and other assets restored—it is impossible to speak of a functional world order or a secure system of rights for individuals and nations. The Turkish state, far from showing contrition, persists in its policy of genocidal intent and expansionism toward Armenia and its people. New allegations of criminal conduct accrue daily, even as clear evidence establishes both individual criminal culpability and state responsibility.
The history of Western Armenia under the rule of the Ottoman Empire is defined by hardship and dark tribulation. It is a chronicle of the horrific and indescribable plight of the Armenian people. Between the 11th and 15th centuries, waves of semi-nomadic Turkic tribes from Central Asia invaded the Armenian Highlands and the South Caucasus annexing the homeland of the Armenian people—an expansion that met with fierce, stubborn resistance from the Armenians for a millennium. This has been the fundamental driver of strife between the Armenians and Turks over the centuries.
Falling under the Ottoman yoke, the Armenian population faced harsh ethno-religious oppression, systemic persecution, and profound social exploitation. Armenian arable lands were progressively expropriated, eventually concentrating in the hands of the Ottoman Turks. The second-class legal status of the Armenians as non-Muslims (dhimmi) likewise became intolerable. Armenians’ testimony was inadmissible in court; they were forbidden from mounting a horse or bearing arms, required to yield the right-of-way to Muslims, and required to differentiate themselves through their attire. And a special poll tax, the kharja (jizya), was levied on the Armenians as non-Muslims. Armenian women and young girls were seized to populate the harems of the sultan and local beys. Armenian children were torn from their parents, and the Armenian population was brutalized and dehumanized, slaughtered and enslaved, with public beheadings commonplace. They were deprived of the right to own property, livestock, or even a home. Forced Islamization and Turkification of the Armenians were routine practices. This systematic dehumanization left the Armenian population in a state of perpetual terror, entirely deprived of the minimal conditions for a peaceful life or livelihood.
Then, in the wake of the 1878 Russo-Turkish War, the Armenian Question emerged as a distinct component of the wider Eastern Question. Article 61 of the 1878 Treaty of Berlin mandated a series of reforms within Ottoman-ruled Western Armenia, guaranteed by Russia, Great Britain, France, Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy. However, these reforms were never implemented because the Armenians inhabited a territory that Turkey deemed vital for the realization of its Pan-Turanian, imperialist ambitions; thus, Article 61 remained a dead letter. The European guarantor powers simply acquiesced to these blatant and cynical violations of international obligations. Meanwhile, the Turkish ruling elite openly asserted that the Armenian Question could only be settled by eliminating the Armenian population. Kiamil Pasha, the head of the Ottoman government at the time, explicitly advocated resolving the issue through the extermination of the Armenian nation, infamously declaring: “If there are no Armenians, there is no Armenian Question.”
While Article 61 of the Treaty of Berlin was lauded as a monumental triumph for Great Britain—bringing home “peace with honor”—David Lloyd George, who served as Prime Minister from 1916 to 1922, wrote critically of this legacy… “Armenia was sacrificed to the triumphal altar we had erected. The Russians were forced to withdraw; the wretched Armenians were once more crushed under the heel of their old oppressors who had bound themselves ‘to carry out improvements and reforms in the provinces inhabited by the Armenians.’ We all know how these obligations were broken for forty years, in spite of the repeated protests of the country which was chiefly responsible for restoring Armenia to Turkish rule. The policy of the British Government led with fatal inevitability to the terrible massacres of 1895–97 and of 1909, and to the wholesale slaughter of 1915.” (David Lloyd George, Memoirs of the Peace Conference, vol. 2 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1939), 811; published in Russian as Л. Джордж, Правда о мирных договорах, т. 2 (Москва: Издательство иностранной литературы, 1957), стр. 390). The Ottoman government adopted the explicit policy of exterminating the Armenian population within the empire, of which Western Armenia was a part. This reality was unequivocally reflected in the text of a resolution adopted on July 26, 1895, following a speech delivered by former British Prime Minister William Gladstone at a public meeting in Chester, which declared:
That this meeting expresses its conviction that Her Majesty’s Government will have the hearty support of the entire nation, without distinction of party, in any measures it may adopt to secure for the population of Turkish Armenia such reforms in the administration of that province as shall provide real guarantees for the life, honor, religion, and property of the inhabitants, and that no reforms can be effective which are not placed under the continuous control of the Great Powers of Europe. (See The Times, London, July 27, 1895, p. 11; (Положение армян в Турции до вмешательства держав в 1895 году, СПб, 1896, стр. XX–XXVIII).
With the outbreak of World War I, the Ottoman Empire joined the Central Powers, seeking thereby to fulfill its Pan-Turanian designs on the populations of the South Caucasus and Central Asia. This geopolitical alignment placed the Armenian population in an existentially perilous position. They inhabited the very territory that lay on the path from Anatolian Turkey through the South Caucasus to Central Asia. Moreover, approximately 2.5 million Armenians lived in the Ottoman Empire, while 1.7 million resided in Russia, primarily in the South Caucasus. In short, the Armenian people of the Armenian Highlands and the South Caucasus stood in the way of Turkey’s Pan-Turanian expansionist ambitions. Taking advantage of the turmoil of the First World War, the Ottoman Empire launched its plan for the total annihilation of the Armenian population, both in the Armenian Highlands and throughout the South Caucasus. The German Ambassador to Turkey Hans von Wangenheim, British political scientist Herbert Adams Gibbons, Ottoman historian Lord Kinross, American diplomat Lewis Einstein, Turkish politician Mevlan Zade Rifat, and others observe that the Ottoman state initiated the mass extermination and deportation of the Armenians following the first phase of the Dardanelles Campaign (February 19 – March 18, 1915). After the Allied naval forces suffered an unexpected defeat during this opening phase of the war, the Ottoman authorities realized that no external power was in a position to stop them. (See Winston S. Churchill, The World Crisis, vol. 2 (London, 1923) (Russian edition, Moscow-Leningrad, 1932), pp. 276–277; Herbert Adams Gibbons, The Blackest Page of Modern History: Events in Armenia in 1915 (New York, 1916); (Russian edition, Petrograd, 1916), p. 26; Lord Kinross, The Ottoman Centuries: The Rise and Fall of the Turkish Empire (London, 1977), p. 607; Lewis Einstein, Inside Constantinople: A Diplomatist’s Diary During the Dardanelles Expedition, April–September, 1915 (New York, 1918), p. 7; Mevlan Zade Rifat, Dark Portals of the Ottoman Empire and the Unionist Scheme of Armenian Extermination (in Armenian, Yerevan, 1990), pp. 133–134). In the ensuing decades, the Turkish state, refusing to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, has maintained that these catastrophic events did not constitute genocide, but were rather ‘acts of war,’ in spite of the fact that Article I of Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 9, 1948, explicitly states that genocide is a crime under international law, whether committed in time of peace or in time of war.
From 1915 to 1923, the Ottoman government, acting with specific intent (dolus specialis) and systematic consistency, executed the mass extermination and deportation of the empire’s Armenian population. This represented a calculated act of genocide designed to eliminate the Armenian people, the indigenous population of the Armenian Highlands. By January 1915, Armenian soldiers and gendarmes serving in the Ottoman forces had already been disarmed and consolidated into labor battalions (amele taburları) of 500 to 1,000 men under the pretext of road construction or border works, only to be systematically led away in groups to remote areas and executed. On April 24 and 25, 1915, approximately 800 prominent intellectuals—including writers, poets, lawyers, doctors, clergymen, and political figures—were arrested, deported, and subsequently murdered. This systematically achieved the near-total annihilation of the Armenian intelligentsia within the Ottoman Empire at the time. Adhering to a highly coordinated plan, the regime ordered the deportation of the Armenian population from the six eastern vilayets—Trebizond, Erzerum, Bitlis, Van, Diarbekir, Kharpert, and Sivas—which comprised Western Armenia proper. The execution of this plan was entrusted to the ‘Special Organization’ (Teşkilât-ı Mahsusa). Led by Behaeddin Shakir, this apparatus was staffed with violent criminals and released convicts, specifically trained and equipped by the Committee of Union and Progress (Ittihad ve Terakki). Although the deportation decrees were proclaimed publicly as routine war-time measures, the process was meticulously designed for its ulterior purpose. The initial phase involved neutralizing prominent community leaders and able-bodied men; subsequently, the deportees—consisting almost entirely of the elderly, women, and children—were rounded up and driven on death marches to concentration camps in the Syrian desert. Along the Black Sea coast and on the Euphrates and Tigris rivers, barges were packed to capacity with people and then deliberately sunk, drowning those on board. Soldiers, gendarmes, brigands, and others plundered and looted the depopulated towns and cities of Western Armenia proper. The Turkish authorities actively encouraged this pillaging, looting, torture, and murder, while severely punishing any attempt to protect the Armenians.
On May 24, 1915, Great Britain, France, and Russia issued a joint declaration officially characterizing the Ottoman government’s actions against the Armenians as ‘crimes against humanity and civilization’—marking the first use of this term in international diplomacy—and holding all members of the Ottoman government personally responsible. The Allied powers demanded an immediate halt to the massacres. Nevertheless, the Ottoman state’s atrocities continued unabated. Out of an initial population of 1.2 million Armenians in Western Armenia proper, only about 300,000 managed to escape to the Caucasus. The remainder were either massacred on the spot or deported, with an estimated 200,000 women and children separated from their families and forcibly assimilated. By late July 1915, the Ottoman government expanded the deportations to the Armenians of Anatolia and Cilicia. Forced into death marches southward, their numbers wasted away. From Aleppo, the survivors were sent further south into the deserts of Syria and Mesopotamia. Concurrently, other columns of Armenians were marched along the Euphrates River toward Deir ez-Zor; approximately 200,000 survived to reach this final destination. Between March and August 1916, the Ottoman government ordered the systematic liquidation of the last remaining survivors held in concentration camps along the Baghdad Railway and the banks of the Euphrates. Nevertheless, a small remnant of the Armenian population survived in the interior—primarily Protestant and Catholic communities whose lives were spared through the targeted humanitarian interventions of American missionaries and the Apostolic Nuncio. Elsewhere, desperate acts of armed self-defense and resistance erupted in several key areas, most notably in Van, Urfa, Shabin-Karahisar, and Musa Dagh. In the eastern provinces, a significant portion of the population of the Van Vilayet managed to retreat alongside Russian forces, thereby escaping total annihilation. Similarly, the majority of the Armenian populations in Constantinople and Smyrna were spared from deportation; in Smyrna and Adrianople, the local Armenians were saved primarily due to the decisive personal intervention of German General Otto Liman von Sanders. In Western Armenia proper, however, the Armenian presence was entirely eradicated. The few survivors of the massacres sought refuge in Syria and Lebanon, while others managed to reach the safety of the Transcaucasus. Ultimately, out of an estimated pre-war population of 2.5 million Armenians in the Ottoman Empire, approximately 1.5 million perished. The survivors scattered globally, finding refuge in the Russian Empire, Syria, Lebanon, the United States, Europe, and beyond, forming the modern Armenian Diaspora.
Talaat, the principal orchestrator of the Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire, notoriously boasted to the United States Ambassador to Turkey, Henry Morgenthau (1913–1916): “I have accomplished more toward solving the Armenian problem in three months than Abdul Hamid accomplished in thirty years!” He added later that the Armenian question no longer existed because the Armenians themselves were no more (Henry Morgenthau, Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1918) p. 342).
In May 1918, the Ottoman army invaded the Transcaucasus, capturing Gyumri (then Alexandropol) on May 15. During those fateful days in Batumi, Djemal Pasha, one of the leading figures of the Young Turk triumvirate—declared to the Armenian diplomat Alexander Khatisian: “The Armenians were and remain our enemies, and they will never leave our Anatolian provinces in peace. It is better to thoroughly eradicate them in the Caucasus, just as was done in Turkey. Otherwise, a small Armenia in the Caucasus will inevitably seek to expand its borders, posing a permanent danger to Turkey.” On May 21, the Ottoman army pushed into the Ararat Valley with the explicit intent of wiping out the Eastern Armenian population. However, in the fierce, existential battles waged between May 21 and 28, 1918, at Sardarapat, Bash-Aparan, and Karakilisa, the Armenian forces successfully routed the numerically superior Ottoman troops. This heroic defense saved the nation from physical annihilation, paving the way for Eastern Armenia to declare its independence on May 28, 1918, as the Republic of Armenia. Shortly thereafter, on June 4, 1918, the newly proclaimed republic was forced to sign a peace treaty with the Ottoman Empire in Batumi. Under its draconian terms, the Armenian state was reduced to a mere 11,000 square kilometers (often cited as 9,000 to 11,000 due to disputed borders) with a population of approximately 321,000. Ultimately, this treaty was never ratified, having been rendered obsolete by the Ottoman capitulation under the Armistice of Mudros on October 30, 1918. Under the terms of the armistice, the Ottoman Empire was obligated to withdraw its forces from the Transcaucasus, including Kars, Ardahan, and Batumi. Yet, prior to the capitulation at Mudros, the Ottoman army had already advanced into Javakhk in May 1918. This incursion resulted in the deportation of 80,000 local Armenians, of whom between 35,000 and 40,000 perished from starvation, exposure, and disease. In September 1918, Ottoman forces orchestrated the slaughter of approximately 30,000 Armenians in Baku. Even after its formal capitulation, Turkey—acting in concert with the local Transcaucasian Tatars (officially designated as Azerbaijanis from 1936 onward)—continued its campaign of violence, culminating in the systematic destruction of the Armenian population of Shushi in Nagorno-Karabakh on March 23, 1920, which resulted in the killing or forced displacement of some 35,000 Armenians. In the course of the onslaught, Shushi’s Armenian churches, schools, historic neighborhoods, and homes were systematically pillaged and reduced to ashes.
Between 1920 and 1921, Turkish nationalist forces occupied the greater part of Armenia—including Shirak, Lori-Pambak, Surmalu, and Kars—massacring over 100,000 Armenians and leaving some 56,000 permanently disabled. From the Kars oblast alone, approximately 130,000 Armenians were forcibly displaced and deported; by March 1921, Armenian presence in this region was completely eradicated, leaving not a single Armenian behind. The Turkish occupying forces finally withdrew from Alexandropol (modern-day Gyumri) on April 22, 1921, only after direct intervention and demands from the Moscow, leaving behind a trail of catastrophic plunder and devastation.
Following Mudros Armistice, world-wide public opinion demanded that Turkey and those members of its government responsible for the atrocities against the Armenians be brought to justice. On April 3, 1919, Rear Admiral Richard Webb, the British Assistant High Commissioner in Constantinople, dispatched a telegram conveying this urgent demand directly to the Paris Peace Conference. This was the unified stance of all the victorious Allied Great Powers participating in the Paris Peace Conference, including the United States. (Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States (1919)The Paris Peace Conference, vol. VI, p. 858). In an effort to distance itself from the thoroughly compromised Young Turk (Ittihadist-Unionist) regime, the new Ottoman cabinet led by Grand Vizier Ahmed Izzet Pasha decided to prosecute the leaders of the wartime government and the Central Committee members of the Committee of Union and Progress. The charges brought against them included entering the Ottoman Empire into World War I and orchestrating the deportations and massacres of the Armenian population. Consequently, during the trials held between April and July 1919, the Ottoman government itself officially recognized the reality of the systematic mass extermination of the Armenian population. In conducting these extraordinary courts-martial, the state gathered extensive documentary evidence regarding the organization of the deportations and massacres. Ultimately the extraordinary court-martial tried and convicted the key members of the Ittihadist cabinet, sentencing the principal architects of the Armenian Genocide—Talaat Pasha, Enver Pasha, and Djemal Pasha—to death in absentia.
These judicial verdicts were presented to the Paris Peace Conference in June 1919 by the new Ottoman Grand Vizier, Damad Ferid Pasha. In his diplomatic address, Damad Ferid similarly cast sole blame upon the Young Turk regime for orchestrating the massacres and deportations, attempting to absolve the broader Turkish population of responsibility and thereby shield the Ottoman Empire from imminent partition. However, Arthur Balfour—who served as British Prime Minister from 1902 to 1906 and as Foreign Secretary from 1916 to 1919—cogently argued that the systematic extermination and deportation of the Armenians within the Ottoman Empire were driven not only by political, national, ethnic, and racial motivations, but also by deeply rooted religious animus: “…in this instance, only the massacre of the Armenian Christians, carried out by order of the Turkish Government, had the flavour of deliberate religious fanaticism.” (D. Lloyd George, The Truth About the Peace Treaties, (Russian translation, Д. Л. Джордж, «Правда о мирных договорах», vol. II, p. 206).
The Armenian Genocide—comprising mass deportations and systematic massacres between 1915 and 1922—bore the distinct character of a continuing crime. Rather than a series of isolated events, it was executed unremittingly through numerous interconnected episodes, expanding far beyond the borders of the Ottoman Empire into the Transcaucasus, including the Kars oblast, the Surmalu district, the First Republic of Armenia, Soviet Armenia, Javakhk, Baku, and Nagorno-Karabakh.
Turkey’s genocidal and expansionist designs on Armenia and the Armenian people were formally institutionalized in the Treaty of Moscow on March 16, 1921, and further cemented in the Treaty of Kars on October 13, 1921, signed with the participation of the Russian SFSR between Turkey and the Soviet Republics of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Georgia. These designs were also reflected in the infamous decision of the Caucasus Bureau (Kavbiuro) of the Russian Communist Party on July 5, 1921. Under these treaties, Turkey secured Western Armenia, the Kars oblast, and the Surmalu district. Meanwhile, the Nakhichevan region was severed from the Armenian SSR and established as an autonomous territory under the protectorate of Azerbaijan. Ultimately, driven by Turkish-Azerbaijani solidarity and the pro-Turkish stance of the Kremlin, the Kavbiuro decision of July 5, 1921, severed Nagorno-Karabakh from Armenia and transferred it to Azerbaijan.
Under the Franco-Turkish Agreement of October 20, 1921, Cilicia was ceded to Turkey. Meanwhile, the Treaty of Sèvres of August 10, 1920—which had recognized an Armenian state encompassing vast territories within the vilayets of Trebizond, Erzurum, Van, and Bitlis—was never ratified, leaving the Armenian Question unresolved.
On April 26, 1920, the San Remo Conference requested that the United States assume a mandate over Armenia and, regardless of Washington’s final decision, appealed to President Woodrow Wilson to arbitrate the frontier between the Armenian state and Turkey. Although Wilson’s historic arbitral award of November 22, 1920, formally established the territorial boundaries of the Armenian state, by then the First Republic of Armenia in the Transcaucasus was already in its final, agonizing days. Ultimately, the US Senate formally rejected the proposed Armenian mandate, and on July 24, 1923, the Allied Powers and Kemalist Turkey signed the Treaty of Lausanne, which completely omitted any mention of Armenia or the rights of its people. As Winston Churchill famously observed: “In the Treaty of Lausanne, which registered the final peace between Turkey and the Great Powers, history will search in vain for the name of ‘Armenia’” (W. Churchill, The World Crisis, Russian trans. В. Черчиль, “Мировой кризис”, p. 279).
Following the Treaty of Lausanne on July 24, 1923, the Ottoman Empire was dissolved, leaving the Republic of Turkey as its continuing state under international law, with an area of approximately 780,600 square kilometers. Ninety-seven percent of this territory lay within the Armenian Highlands and the Anatolian peninsula, while only three percent remained in Europe (Eastern Thrace, on the southeastern Balkan peninsula). This geopolitical eastward pivot had been candidly articulated years prior. On June 4, 1918, during the Batum negotiations, Vehib Pasha, the commander-in-chief of the Ottoman Third Army on the Caucasus Front, told Armenian diplomats point blank: “You see that destiny is driving Turkey from the West to the East. We have left the Balkans, and we are also leaving Africa, but we must expand toward the East: there lies our blood, our religion, and our language. And this is an elemental attraction. Our brothers are in Baku, Dagestan, Turkestan… You must step aside and clear a path for us. This is where our primary dispute lies… You may remain within the confines of Novo-Bayazet [now the Gavar region of the Republic of Armenia—author’s note] and Etchmiadzin.” (Խատիսեան, Ալեքսանդր։ Հայաստանի Հանրապետութեան ծագումն ու զարգացումը։ Աթէնք, 1930, էջ 86, Alexander Khatisian, The Origin and Development of the Republic of Armenia (in Armenian) (Athens, 1930), p. 86). In May 1918, Behaeddin Shakir, the head of the Ottoman ‘Special Organization’ (Teşkilât-ı Mahsusa), similarly declared to Armenian diplomats: “The Armenians stand in the way of realizing our Pan-Islamic and Pan-Turkic sacred ideals, and we are bound to clash with them… On our path, we are forced to ruthlessly destroy anything that acts as an obstacle to the fulfillment of our sacred national ideals” (Ibid., p. 77).
This explains why Turkey persistently displays a genocidal and expansionist stance toward Armenia and the Armenian people—who inhabit a territory that Turkey, even to this day, considers vital for the realization of its Pan-Turkic and Pan-Turanian imperialist ambitions, thereby placing the peoples of the Transcaucasus and Central Asia in harm’s way. Turkey not only refuses to recognize the Armenian Genocide it perpetrated between 1915 and 1922, but also continues to commit similar atrocities to this day. Turkey’s denial persists despite the fact that since 1965, the Armenian Genocide has been officially recognized and condemned by numerous states worldwide—including Uruguay, Cyprus, Argentina, Russia, Greece, Lebanon, Belgium, the Republic of Armenia, the Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) Republic, Italy, France, the Holy See (Vatican City), Switzerland, Canada, Slovakia, the Netherlands, Poland, Venezuela, Lithuania, Chile, Sweden, Bolivia, Austria, Germany, Luxembourg, Syria, Brazil, and the United States, among others.
Turkey’s drive to destroy Armenia and the Armenian people was and remains so profound that, with the diplomatic backing of Great Britain and the United States at the Potsdam Conference (July 17 – August 2, 1945), it resisted the return of the Kars region to the USSR. In this regard, Joseph Stalin remarked: “…But we consider the border in the area of Kars and Ardahan to be incorrect…” (G. Azatyan, Fateful Treaties (Yerevan, 2000), in Russian original, Г. Азатян, «Судьбаносные договора», Ереван, 2000, p. 101-104).
Following the courts-martial of the Ittihadists between April and July 1919, Turkey reversed its policy, embarking on a path of official state denial. A society that fails to acknowledge its own atrocities and turns a blind eye to its inhumanity is fundamentally predisposed to continue or repeat such cruelty. Because no meaningful action was taken to hold the Turkish state accountable for the perpetration of the Armenian Genocide, Adolf Hitler could later infamously remark: “Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?” (Staub Ervin, The Roots of Evil. The Origins of Genocide and other Group Violence (Cambridge University, 1989) p. 183, 184, 187). The mass slaughter and genocide of the Armenian people in the Ottoman Empire is analogous to the Holocaust. Indeed, Turkey’s systematic destruction of the Armenian population during the First World War serves as the direct precursor to the Holocaust.
Following the international military tribunal conducted by Great Britain, the United States, and the Soviet Union in Nuremberg, Germany, from November 20, 1945, to October 1, 1946—which culminated in the death sentences handed down on September 30 and October 1, 1946—the post-war international order began to systematically confront the gravest of international crimes: the mass extermination of entire peoples. The Nuremberg Principles were subsequently affirmed by United Nations General Assembly Resolution 95(I) on December 11, 1946. Japanese war criminals of the Second World War were likewise prosecuted and punished at the Tokyo Trials, which took place from May 3, 1946, to November 12, 1948. Ultimately, specific atrocities were formally codified as crimes against humanity: “genocide” under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide of December 9, 1948; “racism and racial discrimination” under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination of December 21, 1965; and “apartheid” under the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid of 1973. Under the UN Convention on the Non-Applicability of Statutory Limitations to War Crimes and Crimes Against Humanity of November 26, 1968, statutes of limitation were permanently abolished. Furthermore, the legal framework of the Universal Declaration of the Rights of Peoples (Algiers, July 4, 1976) was fundamentally predicated on the concept of preventing genocide. Article 1 of the Algiers Declaration states: “Every people has the right to existence.” According to Article 2: “Every people has the right to the respect of its national and cultural identity.” Article 3 dictates: “Every people has the right to retain peaceful possession of its territory and to return to it if it has been expelled.” Article 4 declares: “No one shall be subjected, because of his national or cultural identity, to massacre, torture, persecution, deportation, expulsion or living conditions such as may compromise the integrity of the people to which he belongs.”
Pursuant to Article II of the United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, adopted by the General Assembly on December 9, 1948, and entering into force on January 12, 1951, genocide is defined as any of the following acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial, or religious group, as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
According to Article III, the following acts shall be punishable:
(a) Genocide;
(b) Conspiracy to commit genocide;
(c) Direct and public incitement to commit genocide;
(d) Attempt to commit genocide;
(e) Complicity in genocide.
Article IV of the Convention stipulates that persons committing genocide or any of the other acts enumerated above shall be punished, whether they are constitutionally responsible rulers, public officials or private individuals. Article IX of the Convention explicitly stipulates that a state committing genocide bears international responsibility for its actions. Consequently, the Turkish state is legally accountable for the Armenian Genocide perpetrated between 1915 and 1922. The Turkish state must bear this responsibility and cannot invoke a break in state continuity as a pretext to evade its international legal obligations. This state responsibility entails an explicit obligation to officially recognize both the fact of the Armenian Genocide and the immense injury suffered by the Armenian people as a result. The United Nations and each of its member states possess the legal right to demand this recognition and to assist the victimized Armenian people in this regard. Article I of the Convention stipulates that genocide is a crime under international law. This category of crime existed prior to December 9, 1948, even though the specific term “genocide” was only codified by the 1948 Convention. Furthermore, the acts described by the term “genocide” had long been recognized as criminal, including during the period of 1915–1922, when Turkey perpetrated the massacres and deportations of the Armenians (i.e., Armenocide). Turkey’s recognition of the Armenian Genocide is itself a fundamental step in the global struggle against this heinous crime.
The fact remains that Turkey steadfastly denies its perpetration of the Armenian Genocide, which stands as the twentieth century’s first systematic act of its kind. Turkey’s impunity to date has served as a dangerous precedent, directly contributing to the subsequent proliferation of genocide and its attendant horrors globally. Regrettably, Turkey itself has not only failed to reckon with its history, but also, in recent years, has continued to aggressively manifest genocidal policies and expansionist ambitions toward the Armenian people. Specifically, during the volatile political crisis in Syria, the Turkish Republic utilized its proxy military formations between March 21 and March 23, 2014, to occupy the town of Kessab and terrorize its population of two thousand Armenians, “deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction.” By causing severe harm to their health and executing targeted killings, Turkey forcibly expelled the population, dispersing them worldwide. In response to these actions, formal diplomatic notes of protest were issued to the Turkish Republic by the United States, Russia, and the Republic of Armenia
Between 2020 and 2023, Turkey—in tandem with Azerbaijan and through the geopolitical acquiescence of Russia—orchestrated the destruction of the Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) Republic. By deliberately inflicting “conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction,” these powers forcibly deported its entire Armenian population of over 150,000, dispersing them worldwide.
Consequently, through its persistent manifestation of genocidal policy and expansionism targeting the Armenian people—both in the Syrian town of Kessab between March 21 and March 23, 2014, and in the Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) Republic between 2020 and 2023—Turkey effectively continued the Armenian Genocide that it initiated on April 24, 1915, in Constantinople.
The Armenian Genocide perpetrated by the Turkish state is characterized as a continuing international crime on the grounds that it has been permanently perpetuated for over 111 years. Its foundational phase traces back to the Hamidian Massacres of 1894–1896 across Asia Minor and Mesopotamia, as well as the Cilicia Massacres of 1909, serving as the precursor to the systematic extermination initiated on April 24, 1915, in Constantinople, and persisting to this day. These atrocities established the operational template for the 1915 Genocide and its modern echoes in Kessab and Nagorno-Karabakh.
The Turkish state is thus properly categorized as a highly dangerous recidivist actor perpetrating a continuing genocide against the Armenians. The ultimate objective of this policy is the total “ethnic cleansing” of the South Caucasus of its Armenian population, ensuring they “no longer obstruct”’ the realization of pan-Turkic and pan-Turanian imperialist ambitions.
With absolute impunity, Turkey has systematically “rid” itself of the Armenian populations of Western Armenia, Cilicia, the Kars region, the Surmalu district, Nakhichevan, Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh), and Eastern Transcaucasia by committing genocide against them—a grave crime against humanity and civilization. At present, Turkey, in tandem with Azerbaijan, is actively intent upon the liquidation of the Republic of Armenia and the definitive “closure” of the Armenian Question. Decisive action by the global Armenian community and the international society to jointly contain Turkey and Azerbaijan—and rescue the Republic of Armenia from the brink—is long overdue.
The genocide and ethnic cleansing of Armenians by Turkish forces in Kessab in 2014, and in Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) during 2020–2023, serve as a stark reminder that the ideology and policies of Pan-Turkism continue to pose an existential threat to the Armenian people.
In the final analysis, for global security, Turkey must reckon with its past, while the international community, Armenia, and the Armenian diaspora must decisively counter the ongoing threats posed by Turkey’s genocidal and expansionist policies.
To this end, this work aims to present this item of unfinished international legal business to a wide readership.
SUMMARY
This work provides a comprehensive analysis of the evidence regarding Turkey’s continuing genocidal and expansionist policy toward Armenia and the Armenian people, specifically spanning the last 111 years. It demonstrates that through these atrocities, Turkey has pursued—and continues to pursue—the goal of the total destruction of the Armenian nation in order to usurp and appropriate its ancestral lands in the Armenian Highlands and Transcaucasia.
This volume comprises a Russian-language study—featuring a preface, three primary chapters, and a summary—accompanied by a complete English translation and an extended Armenian abstract.
The first part of the work presents the dire plight of the Western Armenians in the Ottoman Empire, where the oppressive regime of the Sultan trampled upon all civil and political rights of the Armenian population. As Christians, Armenians were not equal subjects. Their testimony in court was not recognized; they were prohibited from riding horses or carrying arms, and were obliged to yield the right-of-way to a Muslim and distinguish himself by his attire. Devastating raids were routinely conducted by nomadic tribes and marauding bands. In the course of these wars and raids, Western Armenia was laid waste, and the Armenian population— denied basic physical security and the means to live and work in peace—suffered massacres and captivity. It was against this backdrop that the Armenians initiated their national liberation struggle against Ottoman despotism.
Following the Russo-Turkish War of 1877–1878, the security and civil rights of the Ottoman Armenian population transformed from an internal empire matter into an internationalized element of the Eastern Question. Article 61 of the Treaty of Berlin (1878) stipulated the implementation of a series of reforms in the Armenian-populated provinces, with Great Britain, Russia, France, Germany, Austria-Hungary, and Italy acting as international guarantors. Article 61 reads as follows: “The Sublime Porte undertakes to carry out, without further delay, the improvements and reforms demanded by local requirements in the provinces inhabited by the Armenians, and to guarantee their security against the Circassians and Kurds. It will periodically make known the steps taken to this effect to the Powers, who will superintend their application.”
Contrary to these commitments, Sultan Abdul Hamid II and his government, aided by the collusion and negligence of the Great Powers acting as guarantors, refused for forty years to implement these reforms. Instead, they executed a policy aimed at the total destruction of the Western Armenians, guided by the dictum: “The way to get rid of the Armenian Question is to get rid of the Armenians.” British Prime Minister David Lloyd George (1916–1922) held his own country primarily culpable for returning Armenia to Ottoman domination, explicitly acknowledging: “The action of the British Government led inevitably to the terrible massacres of 1895–1896, 1909 and worst of all to the holocausts of 1915…” (David Lloyd George, The Truth about the Peace Treaties (London: Victor Gollancz, 1938, Vol. II, pp. 1256–1257).
At the outbreak of World War I, the Ottoman Empire aligned itself with the German Bloc, as Germany promised to facilitate the realization of Pan-Turkic and Pan-Turanian ambitions across Transcaucasia and Central Asia—territories between which the Armenian homeland geographically lay. Driven by these expansionist aims, the Ottoman state commenced the ruthless extermination of the Armenian nation, perpetrating genocide—“crimes against humanity,” as formally denounced in the Joint Declaration issued by Great Britain, France, and Russia on May 24, 1915. In this milestone declaration, the Allied Powers explicitly held the members of the Ottoman government individually and collectively responsible for these atrocities.
Under the direct orders of the Ottoman government during World War I, approximately 1.5 million Armenians were murdered and nearly 1 million were deported. As the principal architect of the Armenian Genocide, Interior Minister Talaat Pasha, arrogantly declared to the United States Ambassador Henry Morgenthau (quoting Talaat Pasha): “‘I have accomplished more in three months toward solving the Armenian question than Abdul Hamid accomplished in thirty years… The Armenian question is no more, because the Armenians are no more.’” (Henry Morgenthau, Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story (Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1918) p. 342).
The first part of this work conclusively demonstrates that the plans for the Armenian Genocide were secretly formulated by the Young Turk government prior to the outbreak of World War I, while the mass extermination of the Armenians was executed under the cover of war and under the pretext of state “self-preservation.” This very rationale was later invoked by Adolf Hitler, who famously remarked: “Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?” (Staub Ervin, The Roots of Evil: The Origins of Genocide and Other Group Violence (Cambridge: Cambridge University, 1989) pp. 183-187; Hitler, Adolf, Obersalzberg Speech to Wehrmacht Commanders (August 22, 1939); cited in Nuremberg Trial Documents as Document L-3 / Exhibit USA-28).
Much like Ottoman Turkey, the Nazi regime systematically corralled and exterminated the Jews and Slavic peoples during World War II. The mass murder of the Armenian nation in the Ottoman Empire is legally and historically analogous to the Holocaust, serving as its direct precursor.
The first part of the work particularly emphasizes that even subsequent Ottoman cabinets, between April and July 1919, gathered extensive documentation regarding the deportations and massacres of the Armenians and prosecuted the responsible Young Turk leaders before Extraordinary Military Tribunals—in most cases in absentia. The court convicted the majority of the defendants, sentencing the principal architects of the Armenian Genocide—Talaat, Enver, Djemal, and Dr. Nazım—to death.
In June 1919, the head of the new Ottoman government, Grand Vizier Damad Ferid Pasha, submitted the verdicts of the Turkish Military Tribunals to the Paris Peace Conference. Before the Allied Powers, he officially charged the Young Turk government with full responsibility both for dragging the Ottoman Empire into the war on the side of the German Bloc and for the mass extermination and deportation of the Armenian population, petitioning the Allies not to partition the Ottoman Empire and not to indict the entire Turkish nation for the persecution and massacres of the Armenians. However, British Foreign Secretary (1916–1919) Arthur Balfour explicitly rejected the Grand Vizier’s petition.
Balfour’s formal reply was described by David Lloyd George as a damning “indictment” (David Lloyd George, The Truth About the Peace Treaties. Vol. II. (London: Victor Gollancz, 1938) pp. 1014–1016, 1256–1258). Balfour conclusively demonstrated that the massacre of the Armenians by Ottoman authorities was motivated not only by national, ethnic, racial, and political animus, but also by religious persecution (Ibid.). Indeed, Lloyd George identified the Armenian Genocide as a fundamental moral and political justification for the dismemberment of the Ottoman Empire, asserting: “The Turks slaughtered hundreds of thousands of Armenians and outraged countless Christian women committed to their protection… Through sloth, incompetence, cruelty, and corruption, they turned a flourishing garden into a wilderness… The Turk sold for German money the friends who had repeatedly saved his worthless existence… He plunders, slays, ravished all, cheats, lies, and betrays…” (Ibid., p. 468).
According to the prominent British statesman Sir Winston Churchill: “In 1915 the Turkish Government began and ruthlessly carried out the infamous general massacre and deportation of Armenians in Asia Minor… There is no reasonable doubt that this crime was planned and executed for political reasons. The opportunity presented itself for clearing Turkish soil of a Christian race opposed to all Turkish ambitions, cherishing national ambitions that could only be satisfied at the expense of Turkey, and planted geographically between Turkish and Caucasian Muslim population… According to approximate calculations, 1.4 million Armenians were subjected to these deportations, of whom more than half perished. It may well be that the British attack on the Gallipoli Peninsula stimulated the merciless fury of the Turkish Government. The Turks thought, apparently, that even if Constantinople fell and the war were lost, the clearance of the race from Asia Minor would be an accomplished fact, securing for the Turkish race an advantage vital to its future.” (Winston S. Churchill, The World Crisis: The Aftermath, 1918–1928 (London: Thornton Butterworth, 1929) vol. V, p. 405 [p. 277 in the Russian Edition]).
The second part of this work examines the genocidal and expansionist nature of Turkey’s policy toward Eastern Armenia and the entire Armenian population of Transcaucasia. In this context, it is instructive to cite Djemal Pasha, one of the principal architects of the Armenian Genocide: “The Armenians were and remain our enemies; they will never leave the provinces of our Anatolia in peace. It is better to thoroughly eradicate them in the Caucasus as well, just as was done in Turkey. A small Armenia in the Caucasus will inevitably seek to expand its borders and remain an eternal threat to Turkey.” (Alexander Khatisian, The Origin and Development of the Republic of Armenia (Athens, 1928) p. 72).
Similarly, during the Batum peace negotiations in May 1918, Dr. Behaeddin Shakir—another key perpetrator of the genocide and leader of the Committee of Union and Progress—explained to the Armenian diplomat Alexander Khatisian the rationale behind the extermination of Armenians across both the Armenian Highlands and the Caucasus: “The Armenians stand directly in the path of realizing our sacred Pan-Islamic and Pan-Turkic ideals, and we inevitably collide with them… We are forced to ruthlessly destroy everything along our way that poses an obstacle to the fulfillment of our national and sacred ideals…” (Ibid., p. 77).
Equally revealing are the declarations made by Vehib Pasha, Commander-in-Chief of the Ottoman Army on the Caucasian Front, to Khatisian in Batum: “You see that destiny is pulling Turkey away from the West and toward the East. We have departed from the Balkans, and we are leaving Africa, but we must expand eastward: our blood, our religion, and our language are there. This is an elemental pull. Our brothers reside in Baku, Dagestan, and Turkestan. And you, Armenians, are standing in our way… You must step aside and clear the path for us. That is the root of our fundamental dispute… You may remain only… around New Bayazet and Etchmiadzin.” (Ibid., p. 86).
Guided by this aggressive doctrine, Ottoman forces invaded the Ararat Valley. However, between May 21 and May 28, 1918, the regular Armenian Army, alongside volunteer militia units, dealt a decisive defeat to the Ottoman forces in fierce battles at Sardarapat, Bash-Aparan, and Karakilisa (modern-day Vanadzor), halting their advance.
In May 1918, Ottoman troops entered Javakheti (Javakhk), resulting in the displacement of approximately 80,000 Armenians into the dense Bakuriani forests, where nearly 40,000 perished from starvation, exposure, and disease (A. A. Melkonyan, Javakhk in the 19th Century and the First Quarter of the 20th Century (in Armenian) p. 352). Subsequently, in September 1918, the Ottoman Army of Islam, in coordination with local Transcaucasian Tatars (officially designated as Azerbaijanis since 1936), executed a three-day massacre in Baku, murdering roughly 30,000 Armenians (V. E. Khodjabekyan, Reproduction and Movements of the Population of Armenia in the 19th–20th Centuries and on the Threshold of the 21st Century (Yerevan: Gitutyun, 2002) (in Armenian) pp. 161–163).
On March 23, 1920, combined Turkish-Azerbaijani forces and armed bands perpetrated a mass murder in the administrative center of Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh)—the city of Shushi—slaughtering 35,000 peaceful Armenian residents and systematically burning their churches, schools, and residential quarters.
In October 1920, Kemalist Turkey occupied Shirak, Lori-Pambak, Surmalu, Alexandropol (Gyumri), Kars, and other Eastern Armenian territories. During this occupation, 100,000 Armenians were killed, 130,000 deported, and 56,000 wounded (A. M. Poghosyan, Social and Economic Relations in the Kars Region (1878–1918) (Yerevan: Haypethrat, 1961) (in Armenian) pp. 376–380; Central State Archive of the Armenian SSR (CSAA / now National Archives of Armenia) (in Russian) Fund 113, Inventory 1, File 96, Folio 1, (CSAA / now National Archives of Armenia) (in Russian) Fund 506, Inventory 1, File 42, Folio 3; Central State Archive of the October Revolution of the Georgian SSR (CSAOR Georgian SSR (in Russian) Fund 61, File 2396, Folio 461). It was only under direct political pressure from Soviet Russia that Turkish forces finally withdrew from the Alexandropol district on April 22, 1921 (Documents on the Foreign Policy of the USSR (DVP SSSR) vol. 4, (Moscow, 1960) (in Russian) pp. 50-123).
Turkey’s genocidal policy toward the Armenian nation resulted in the forcible annexation and dismemberment of ancestral Armenian territories across both the Armenian Highlands and the Caucasus. Through the Moscow Treaty of March 16, 1921, the Treaty of Kars of October 13, 1921, the Franco-Turkish Accord of October 20, 1921, and the decision of the Caucasian Bureau of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks) on July 5, 1921, the vast majority of the historical Armenian homeland was wrested from, and emptied of, its indigenous population. Turkey annexed Western Armenia, Cilicia, the Kars region, and the Surmalu district, while the Nakhichevan region and Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) were handed over to Azerbaijan.
Reflecting upon these geopolitical outcomes, the former Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia, Alexander Khatisian, observed: “Step by step, day after day, I closely examined every influence and reality of foreign policy. I arrived at the unshakeable conviction that the Allied Powers abandoned Armenia, a situation of which the Turks took full advantage. And the principal allies of the Turks in this operation were the Bolsheviks, who provided them with the strength and opportunity to attack Armenia. This is an indisputable fact. Equally undeniable is the fact that, alongside their mutual strategic assistance, they partitioned Armenia between themselves.” (A. Khatisian, op. cit., pp. 292-293).
The second part of this work demonstrated that as a result of Turkey’s expansionist, genocidal policy, the entire Armenian population of Western Armenia, the Kars region, and the Surmalu district was completely eradicated, while its numbers in Transcaucasia were drastically reduced. Nevertheless, the Ottoman Empire recognized the Republic of Armenia in Transcaucasia and subsequently acknowledged an independent Armenia within the vilayets of Trebizond, Erzerum, Van, and Bitlis (pursuant to the Treaty of Sèvres of August 10, 1920). Leaders such as David Lloyd George, Georges Clemenceau, and Woodrow Wilson repeatedly promised to ensure justice for the “long-suffering Armenian people.” However, the Treaty of Sèvres was never ratified, and President Wilson’s Arbitral Award regarding the Armenian-Turkish boundary was issued on November 22, 1920—when the Republic of Armenia was already in its final days. Consequently, Turkey seized all the aforementioned Armenian territories. On July 24, 1923, the Allied Powers and the new Republic of Turkey signed the Treaty of Lausanne, which contained no mention of either Armenia or the rights of the Armenian nation.
The second part of the work demonstrates that even after the Lausanne Conference and the signing of the Treaty of 1923, Turkey did not abandon its expansionist, genocidal policy toward the Armenians. In particular, Turkey was prepared to invade Transcaucasia if the Soviet forces were defeated by Germany in the Battle of Stalingrad (which lasted from July 17, 1942, to February 2, 1943). Such an outcome would have proved catastrophic for the entire Eastern Armenian population. Fortunately, Soviet troops achieved a decisive victory.
Subsequently, from July 17 to August 2, 1945, the Potsdam Conference was held in Germany, attended by Joseph Stalin, Winston Churchill (replaced by Clement Attlee on July 28), and Harry S. Truman. At Potsdam, the USSR, the United Kingdom, and the United States reaffirmed their intention to bring the principal war criminals to justice before an International Military Tribunal. The conference also addressed the territorial issue regarding the return of the Kars region and Ardahan to the Armenian SSR; however, this proposal was thwarted by the opposition of the United States and Great Britain. Concluding the discussion on this matter, Stalin nevertheless asserted: “ …But we consider the border in the area of Kars and Ardahan to be incorrect…” (G. Azatyan, Fateful Treaties (Yerevan, 2000) (in Russian) pp. 101–104).
The third part of the work analyzes the evolution of the international legal order toward progressive codification, as a result of which nations around the world began to officially recognize and condemn the Armenian Genocide perpetrated in the Ottoman Empire between 1915 and 1922. The International Military Tribunals at Nuremberg and Tokyo prosecuted key war criminals, and the principles recognized by their Charters and judgments were formally affirmed by UN General Assembly Resolution 95(I) of December 11, 1946, establishing the foundational legal elements of crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.
Within this emerging legal order, the UN General Assembly adopted the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide on December 9, 1948 (which entered into force on January 12, 1951), the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (December 21, 1965), the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid (November 30, 1973), and the Convention on the Non-Applicability of Statutory Limitations to War Crimes and Crimes Against Humanity (November 26, 1968). Furthermore, on July 4, 1976, the Universal Declaration of the Rights of Peoples was proclaimed in Algiers.
On the basis of these fundamental instruments of international law, the systematic extermination and deportation of the Armenians in the Ottoman Empire fall squarely within the definition of “genocide.” Pursuant to Article II of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, “genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.”
Pursuant to Article III of the Convention, the following acts shall be punishable:
(a) Genocide;
(b) Conspiracy to commit genocide;
(c) Direct and public incitement to commit genocide;
(d) Attempt to commit genocide;
(e) Complicity in genocide.
Article IV of the Convention provides that persons committing genocide or any of the other acts enumerated in Article III shall be punished, whether they are constitutionally responsible rulers, public officials, or private individuals. Article IX of the Convention likewise establishes state responsibility for acts of genocide or any of the other enumerated acts.
The extermination of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire through massacres and forced deportations constitutes the crime of genocide, which is subject to no statutory limitations pursuant to the Convention on the Non-Applicability of Statutory Limitations to War Crimes and Crimes Against Humanity. Turkey must bear international legal responsibility for the commission of the Armenian Genocide between 1915 and 1922 and cannot invoke a break in state continuity as a pretext to evade this liability. This responsibility entails, above all, the formal obligation to officially recognize the reality of this genocide and the profound injury inflicted upon the Armenian nation as a consequence. Furthermore, the United Nations and each of its Member States possess the legal standing to demand such recognition and to render assistance to the Armenian people in this regard.
Genocide and Holocaust scholars Yehuda Bauer (USA) and Ervin Staub (USA), alongside international legal experts Dr. Felix Ermacora (Austria), James R. Russell (USA), Richard Falk (USA), Robert Jay Lifton (USA), Joe Verhoeven (Belgium), and many other specialists have maintained a unified consensus on the following points:
- The Turkish state that emerged following World War I is legally identical to the 1915–1923 state entity that perpetrated the Armenian Genocide; consequently, the current Turkish government cannot relieve itself of international responsibility under the pretext of a purported fundamental breach or discontinuity with the past;
- The Armenian Genocide perpetrated by Turkey between 1915 and 1922 is analogous to the Holocaust and served as its historical harbinger;
- Turkish denial of the Armenian Genocide cannot evade the historical facts—namely, that the Armenian population was deported from its ancestral homeland pursuant to official decrees of the Turkish government, exacting an immense and bloody toll upon the Armenian nation;
- The plans for the Armenian Genocide were formulated in secrecy prior to the outbreak of World War I;
- Very little was done by the international community to punish Turkey for committing the Armenian Genocide, enabling Adolf Hitler to draw inspiration from the Turkish precedent and later declare: “Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?” (Obersalzberg Speech (August 22, 1939);
- Following the 1919 courts-martial condemning the Young Turks of these crimes, Turkey fundamentally reversed its policy and has ever since denied the reality of the 1915–1922 Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire. However, a society that fails to acknowledge the atrocities it has committed and turns a blind eye to its own inhumanity is bound to perpetuate or repeat such acts in the future (Yuri G. Barsegov, ed., The Armenian Genocide: Turkey’s Responsibility and the Obligations of the International Community. Collection of Documents and Materials. (in Russian) Vol. 1., p. 768, 781–784, Docs. Nos. 605, 607–612).
Notwithstanding Turkish denial, the fact of the 1915–1922 Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire has been formally recognized and condemned by numerous states worldwide, including: Uruguay, Cyprus, the Republic of Armenia, Argentina, the Russian Federation, Greece, Lebanon, Belgium, the Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) Republic (April 22, 1998), Italy, France, the Vatican (Holy See; September 27, 2001, and reaffirmed April 24, 2015), Switzerland, Canada, Slovakia, the Netherlands, Poland, Venezuela, Lithuania, Chile, Sweden, Bolivia, Austria, Germany, Luxembourg, Syria, Brazil, the United States, and others. The 1915–1922 Armenian Genocide has likewise been recognized and condemned by a broad spectrum of civic, political, international, and religious bodies globally.
However, Turkey, which continues to deny perpetrating the 1915–1922 Armenian Genocide, continues and repeats such atrocities against the Armenian people in our times. Acting as a recurring perpetrator of genocidal acts against the Armenian population, Turkey—utilizing military-extremist proxy forces under its control—occupied the Armenian-populated enclave of Kessab in Syria (located near the Syrian-Turkish border) on March 21–23, 2014. It deliberately inflicted on Kessab’s 2,000-strong Armenian population conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part, resulting in the forced deportation and dispersion of the Armenians of Kessab across Syria and worldwide.
Through these actions, Turkey committed the crime of genocide against the Armenian population of Kessab—conduct that falls squarely within the definition set forth in Articles II and III of the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (adopted on December 9, 1948). Pursuant to Articles IV and IX of the Convention, both the State of Turkey and the individual perpetrators who committed genocide or related acts against the Kessab Armenians under Articles II and III—are subject to international legal responsibility and individual criminal prosecution.
In 2020–2023, the Turkish State—acting jointly with Azerbaijan and amidst the inaction of the Russian Federation—instigated and supported the war against the unrecognized Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (Republic of Artsakh). Throughout 2020–2023, Turkey, together with Azerbaijan, deliberately inflicted on the Artsakh Armenians conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction, resulting in the ethnic cleansing, forced displacement, and exile of the 150,000-strong Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh from its ancestral homeland.
Thus, in 2020–2023, Turkey and Azerbaijan committed the crime of genocide against the 150,000 Armenians of Karabakh—a grave international crime as codified under Articles II and III of the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide of December 9, 1948. Pursuant to Article IX of this Convention, both Turkey and Azerbaijan bear international legal responsibility and are subject to liability for committing genocide against the Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh in 2020-2023. For its part, the legal and political liability of the Russian Federation warrants separate, comprehensive, and exhaustive inquiry. The continued seizure of historical Armenian territories by Turkey and Azerbaijan under the guise of “military-political partnership” remains impermissible under international law.
In light of the foregoing, we are compelled to conclude that the Armenian Genocide, initiated by Turkey on April 24, 1915, continues to the present day—spanning a period of 111 years—across the Armenian Highlands, Mesopotamia, and the South Caucasus. The legal elements (corpus delicti) of these crimes against humanity, civilization, and international security are established beyond question. Turkey initiated this atrocity against the Armenian nation more than a century ago and continues to perpetrate it in contemporary times with direct intent and the specific genocidal goal (dolus specialis) of appropriating the Armenians’ ancestral homeland in the Armenian Highlands and the South Caucasus. As Turkey and the international community are well aware, the weight of the law and evidence in this case is overwhelming—which is precisely why Turkey desperately pursues a state policy of denying the Armenian Genocide. Today, Turkey has brazenly proceeded toward the execution and ultimate completion of the Armenian Genocide within the Republic of Armenia itself, harboring the objective of dismantling the independent statehood of the Armenian people and permanently closing the Armenian Question. Halting Turkey’s unlawful actions represents an urgent task for the global Armenian nation and the entire international community, led by the United Nations.
Turkey must come to terms with the imperative necessity of recognizing the historical reality of the Armenian Genocide. This is required not only as an indispensable condition for restoring historical justice, human dignity, and compensating for the damage inflicted upon the Armenian nation, but also as a crucial factor in the moral health and standing of Turkish society itself, its integration into the system of international law, and the establishment of good-neighborly relations in the region. Only through a critical reassessment of the past, acknowledgment of state responsibility, and readiness to make reparations is it possible to establish the rule of law, secure global peace, and prevent crimes against humanity in the future.
